Physical vs digital media trends

I was talking to my teenage son about AI, and I asked him what he thought. I wasn't expecting his answer.

Younger members want everything digital. Or do they?

I was talking to my teenage son last week. He’s just finished his A levels, including courses in photography and film production. We were talking about AI and I asked him what he thought.

‘Stop bloody talking about AI, it’s so boring.’

I looked around my son’s bedroom and started to see his point. Vinyl records, cameras – both digital and film – proper photographs on the wall, even a ‘photobooth‘ style set of four images of him and his friends.

It got me thinking.

Want to attract younger members? The common advice is take everything online

It sounds sensible. People who have grown up with smartphones, social media and streaming services will surely want their membership experience delivered through a screen.

But that assumption risks overlooking things younger members actually value, from a printed magazine to the chance to meet face-to-face.

It reminded me of a recent conversation I had with Ruth Bolle of Research by Design, leading member research agency, about how member research has challenged some familiar assumptions about younger audiences. Her observations make a compelling case for understanding your members before deciding how best to communicate with them.

black and gray film camera near printed photos

Growing up with screens doesn’t mean they’re always the best choice

It’s easy to mistake someone’s familiarity with technology for a preference for all things digital.

Younger members may expect to join online, book events on their phones and access professional guidance at the touch of a button. But that doesn’t mean they don’t enjoy, or even prefer, reading a printed magazine.

Ruth described research that found younger people, including students used to learning through screens, valued having a physical publication they could hold and share.

For those already spending much of their working or studying day online, print offers a welcome change. A magazine gives readers the chance to explore a subject without the distraction of another notification.

Of course, that doesn’t mean all younger members prefer print. But age alone isn’t a good enough reason to rule it out.

The networking assumption deserves a rethink too

The same assumptions can influence decisions about events.

If younger members are comfortable connecting online, it might seem logical to prioritise virtual networking. Yet Ruth described research that found younger people were keen to attend face-to-face events and make connections that could help them develop their careers.

Some, however, felt intimidated or unsure how to get involved. Their hesitation could easily be mistaken for a lack of interest.

The solution might be as simple as welcoming first-time attendees, introducing them to other members or organising facilitated discussions to help break the ice.

Before replacing an experience, it’s worth understanding what’s stopping people from taking part.

A generation is not a single audience

Labels such as Gen Z can be a useful starting point, but they’re no substitute for understanding your members.

Two people of the same age can have very different needs. One might be studying full time, another working shifts. One may want to build professional connections, while another is looking for practical advice they can put to use straight away.

Career stage, confidence, interests, accessibility needs and daily routines all influence how people engage.

Rather than making assumptions based on age, it’s worth asking: what are these members trying to achieve and how can our communications help them?

The answers give editorial teams something useful to work with, helping shape the subjects they cover, the voices they include and the formats they choose.

Ask about members’ lives before asking about your channels

Ruth’s approach to research begins with understanding members’ challenges and aspirations.

Rather than asking ‘do you like our magazine?’, start by finding out what members actually need. What challenges are they facing? Where do they turn for advice? What would help them feel more confident or connected?

Then look at how well your existing communications meet those needs.

When reviewing a publication, useful questions include:

  • Which articles have members read, kept, shared or acted on?
  • When and where do they read?
  • What makes content worth returning to?
  • What prevents them from accessing or using a publication?
  • What would they miss if it disappeared?

It’s also important to hear from members who rarely engage, not just your regular readers and most vocal supporters.

Give each channel a clear purpose

Research might show that keeping print is the right choice, or that changing its frequency, improving the digital edition or using a mix of channels would better serve members.

A magazine can offer depth, inspiration and a tangible connection to an organisation. Email is useful for timely updates, while events give members opportunities to build relationships.

Each channel should have a clear purpose and meet a genuine need.

Digital access matters too. Ruth stressed the importance of making information and learning resources easy to find. Just because someone values a printed magazine doesn’t mean they’re happy to navigate multiple online portals to access what they need.

Research before you remove

Discontinuing print is a significant publishing decision. It deserves more consideration than a general assumption about what younger members want.

Before changing formats, find out what members value, how they use your content and whether the proposed alternative will meet the same needs.

At Salt Media, we help membership organisations use reader insights to create engaging publications and joined-up communications. If you’re reviewing your magazine, a content audit and reader research can help identify what’s working, what could be improved and where to invest.

Younger members may well want something different. The important thing is to ask them rather than assume.

If you’d like to discuss how we can help with your membership publications, get in touch.

Do younger members prefer digital communications to print?

Younger members do not all share the same preferences. In the research Ruth discussed some younger people valued physical publications despite regularly studying or working through screens. Membership organisations should research their own readers before assuming that age determines format preference.

Are printed membership magazines still relevant to younger audiences?

Printed membership magazines can be relevant to younger audiences when their content meets a clear need. Practical guidance, career advice and stories from relatable peers can give members reasons to read. Relevance depends on the editorial content, design and reading experience as well as the format.

Should membership organisations replace printed magazines with digital editions?

The decision should be based on reader research, accessibility, costs and the purpose of the publication. Before replacing print, establish who uses it, what they value and whether a digital edition would meet those needs. Test the proposed alternative with members before committing to a permanent change.

Do younger members want face-to-face networking events?

Some younger members value face-to-face networking as an opportunity to meet peers, potential employers and experienced professionals. Ruth Bolle described research where younger people wanted to attend but sometimes felt intimidated. Introductions, facilitated discussions and a welcome for first-time attendees may help remove those barriers.

How can membership organisations find out which communication formats members want?

Combine surveys with interviews, focus groups and evidence of how members use existing communications. Ask what members read, keep, share or act on, alongside their stated preferences. Consider how to engage with less engaged members and people at different career stages to avoid relying solely on the most vocal respondents.

What should a membership magazine reader survey or focus group ask?

A reader survey or focus group should explore which subjects members find useful, when they read, what they remember and whether they act on the content. Ask about accessibility and barriers to reading too. Understanding members’ wider challenges and interests helps explain what the publication needs to deliver.

Explore the website to see examples of our work and case studies with clients in different sectors.
Drop us a line below to find out more about how we may be able to help you with your publishing, marketing and design requirements.
Magazine design

Ready to join the subs club?

Paid-subscription platforms like Patreon and Substack are booming, so how can membership organisations use these platforms to reach a new audience?
Indy Coffee Guide storytelling

5 Ways printed communications grow your business

Digital communications may be the quickest way to reach an audience, but tactile materials are a hugely persuasive tool for engaging customers
storybook open with fairy lights

Storytelling to build your brand

Telling stories forges an emotional connection with your customers, says Nick Cooper
Secret Link